Mortgage questions
When is PMI required?
PMI, short for private mortgage insurance, is required on a conventional loan whenever you put down less than twenty percent of the purchase price, or have less than twenty percent equity when you refinance. It protects the lender, not you, if you stop paying. It is not required on every loan type: FHA loans use their own mortgage insurance, and VA loans generally have none.
PMI exists because your down payment is the lender's cushion
A down payment is the share of the home you own outright from day one. When you put down twenty percent, the lender has a buffer if home values dip and it has to sell the house after a default. Below that threshold, the lender buys insurance against its own loss and passes the cost to you. Here is the everyday version. On a house priced at four hundred thousand dollars, a ten percent down payment means you borrow three hundred sixty thousand dollars. That gap between what you owe and what the home is worth is thin enough that the lender wants protection, so PMI gets added to your monthly payment. PMI is not a one-time fee. It is a monthly charge, usually folded into your payment along with principal, interest, taxes and homeowners insurance. It does nothing for your balance and builds no equity.
Where PMI shows up on your paperwork
Your Loan Estimate lists PMI in two places. The monthly premium appears in Section G, the escrow and other charges section, as part of your estimated escrow payment. Any upfront premium appears in Section B, services you cannot shop for. On the Closing Disclosure, the same figures appear in matching sections, so you can compare the estimate to the final numbers line by line. Your monthly statement will also show the PMI portion separately, or you can ask your servicer to break it out. Ask the loan officer one direct question: what is the monthly PMI amount, and what triggers it to come off? Get the answer in writing, because the removal rules differ between loan types.
The eighty percent line is the whole game
On a conventional loan, you can ask your servicer to cancel PMI once your balance reaches eighty percent of the home's original value, meaning the value at purchase, not today's market value. The lender must also see a clean payment history. If you never ask, PMI ends automatically when your balance is scheduled to reach seventy-eight percent of that original value. That is the borrower's trap: waiting for automatic termination can cost you months of premiums you did not need to pay. Your balance falls two ways. You pay it down with each monthly payment, and you can also make extra principal payments to get there faster. On a loan of three hundred sixty thousand dollars, a few hundred extra dollars a month toward principal can pull the eighty percent date forward by years. A refinance is the other route, but only if rates and closing costs make sense for you.
Other loan types handle insurance differently
FHA loans require mortgage insurance no matter how much you put down, and the structure has an upfront piece plus an annual piece. The annual premium generally lasts for the full loan term when your down payment is under ten percent, so FHA insurance does not simply fall off at eighty percent the way conventional PMI does. That is a real long-term cost to weigh against FHA's lower down payment and credit flexibility. VA loans generally carry no monthly mortgage insurance. There is a one-time funding fee instead, and some borrowers are exempt from it. USDA loans charge their own guarantee fee rather than PMI. So the honest answer to "when is PMI required" depends on the loan program. On a conventional loan, it tracks your down payment and equity. On FHA, it is part of the deal.
How to judge whether a quote with PMI is a good one
Do not compare monthly payments alone. Two quotes can look identical and differ by thousands over the life of the loan once PMI, points and lender credits are counted. Ask each lender for the same four numbers: the interest rate, the monthly PMI amount, the total closing costs, and the date PMI comes off under their program. Then compare the full cost over the years you expect to stay in the home. Ralo is a mortgage broker, which means it arranges your loan with a lender rather than lending the money itself. It charges a thin commission set in advance per lender, and that commission cannot move with your rate or terms. You can check any company's license for free in the public NMLS lookup, and you can use Ralo's published rate index and weekly rate report to see where quotes sit before you call anyone. Ralo is one option among many; a credit union or a direct lender may beat it on a given day, and the only way to know is to compare.
Shopping around does not hurt your credit the way you think
A common worry is that getting several quotes will dent your credit score. Mortgage inquiries inside a short shopping window are scored as a single inquiry, so comparing lenders is not the penalty people fear. The window is longer under newer scoring models than under the oldest ones, so ask each lender which model it uses if this matters to you. Comparing is worth the effort. Research on borrower behavior has found meaningful annual savings from gathering multiple quotes rather than accepting the first offer. And nearly half of borrowers seriously consider only one lender, which means most people never see the second price. Start with your Loan Estimate from one lender, then use it as a template. The same loan amount and term across three lenders makes the PMI line easy to compare.
Figures used on this page
| Figure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| When you can ask to cancel conventional PMI | When the balance reaches 80% of the home’s original value | CFPB |
| When conventional PMI ends automatically | When the balance is scheduled to reach 78% of the original value | CFPB |
| Broker compensation structure | fixed in advance per lender; cannot vary with your rate or terms | CFPB loan originator compensation rule (Regulation Z) |
| Mortgage inquiry dedup window (newer FICO models) | 45 days scored as one inquiry | CFPB |
| Mortgage inquiry dedup window (oldest FICO models) | 14 days scored as one inquiry | CFPB |
| Savings from comparing multiple lender quotes | $600–$1,200 per year | Freddie Mac research |
| Borrowers who seriously consider only one lender | Nearly half | CFPB borrower survey |
| Verifying any mortgage company’s license | free public lookup on NMLS Consumer Access | NMLS Consumer Access |
Ralo is an automated mortgage broker — not a lender — that compares multiple lenders from one application, earns a thin commission, and shows rate, APR, and fees upfront. Rates shown anywhere on this site are illustrative examples, not a loan approval, rate lock, or commitment. Available where licensed: California, Colorado, and Texas.